While Stax had its fair share of hits, they weren’t in it for the commercial reasons Motown seemed to be. Release date: In fact, their first big hit, “Green Onions,” was created by accident during a jam session. Popular Quizzes Today. Required fields are marked *. Location: Arizona. Ultimately I would go with Stax. Not a simple question. Esta semana vuelve nuestro compañero Martin Budin y esta vez a traido a su preparador por que hoy hay combate de sellos. Both Motown and Stax have a legacy of their own in the world of soul and R&B. Grant A Musical Free-Spirit. Stax Records. Like Like. 'Just Because Your Love Has Gone is A Good' example, so really a true case of Stax meets Motown I think! Cheers Paul . One of the baby-boomers most taken with the Motown sound was Randy W. Hall’s father Robert who would buy every Motown (and its subsidiary labels) 45 he could afford and pass that enthusiasm for the labels artists and songs down to his son years later. When it comes to great music, both PIR and Motown have great catalogues. Randy is co-host of That Dandy Classic Music Hour, loves lists, and loves the sound of his own voice. We loved Stax but saw what they were doing as being for a completely different group of fans. Beyond its oversimplification, I’m curious if you – being better-read on the matter – think my musical shorthand is accurate or not. Rate 5 stars Rate 4 stars Rate 3 stars Rate 2 stars Rate 1 star . “Here Is a Look at the Storied History of Stax Records Out of Memphis.” The Balance Careers, The Balance Careers, 2 Apr. I tend to oversimplify in the following way: Motown is sweet and smooth; Marvin Gaye is Motown’s archetypical vocalist. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Love both labels, but I am partial to the Stax sound. Records aimed at white audience Records aimed at R&B audience. Stax showed the world that when it comes to music, black and white doesn’t matter. The Stax headquarters were located in South Memphis in an old theater. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. A playlist featuring Albert King, The Temptations, Jackie Brenston & His Delta Cats, and others In the Hitsville, USA studios on West Grand Boulevard down in Studio A (dubbed the Snakepit by the Funk Brothers) magic was created on a regular basis and not only soul, but also pop, music was never the same. Unlike the mathematical, ultra-sheened approach of its rival label, Stax thrived on their spontaneous, organic approach to music-making which they referred to as “head arrangements”. In 1959, songwriter Berry Gordy founded his company, Motown Records Corporation. Landini said: October 19, 2012 at 2:33 pm. They were committed to the cause of racial integration in the music industry, They didn't hide Booker T and the MGs under the carpet the way that Motown did with the Funk Brothers for so long and their core sound was so much more distinctive. There are several ways to never miss an episode of our show… and it’s free! While Dan of course would hear his share of Motown, and then some, growing up in Detroit, it was the warm, welcoming tones of “Green Onions” he would remember and set him on a path of seeking out the Stax catalog when he got older. These two compilations teasingly measure Stax against two titans of its day in Motown Records and The Beatles. Don’t forget to check out part one. Battle of The Bands: Stax Records vs. Motown, Leon Ware Live at the Charles H. Wright Museum of African American History, Detroit Midsummer Nights In Midtown. Go Orange. Producer/composer most important Performers most important. LOL! Despite these differences, both contributed greatly to music and should be celebrated. The house band, Booker T. and the MG’s, included Booker T. Jones, Steve Cropper, Al Jackson and Lewis Steinberg, although Steinberg was replaced by Donald Dunn after a couple years with the band. Location: NYC USA. One of these companies arose out of the north, which very rigidly rigidly … McDonald, Heather. Some of the artists to come from Stax include Isaac Hayes, Otis Redding, Rufus Thomas, Johnnie Taylor, Albert King, and The Staple Singers. Share this event with your friends. Stax is raw and gritty; Otis Redding is its archetypical vocalist. I think the average man on the street could name far more Motown artists than he could Stax artists. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Sneaky Pete Forum Resident. Motown had a much smoother sound, clean and poppy. Your email address will not be published. In contrast to Motown, Stax had a houseband, Booker T & the MG’s that was front-and-center and was one of the most racially diverse set of artists and staffs in the entertainment business. Stax was much more collaborative and artist driven. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Hey Shindiggers! Ultimately, it’s not a case of either/or. Motown songs were written by songwriters and producers, while Stax songs were created by the performers and were arranged in recording sessions. by ttamttam Plays Quiz not verified by Sporcle . It also played a large role in influencing much of the disco sound of the early-late seventies. The signature sound of Motown was a polished and sophisticated, jazz-influenced soul that showcased smooth vocals in the forefront of the music. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. 18 abril 2018 por Voodoorock. Motown Records is an American record label owned by the Universal Music Group.It was founded by Berry Gordy Jr. as Tamla Records on January 12, 1959, and incorporated as Motown Record Corporation on April 14, 1960. The former was Stax’s main rival (the “Soulsville” nickname derives from Motown’s “Hitsville” reputation), and Stax was often seen as Motown’s scruffy, Southern little brother who countered Holland-Dozier-Holland with Hayes-Porter, Marvin Gaye with Otis Redding, and the production sensibilities of … The two great labels of American soul and R&B. At Motown, we were expected to record four basic tracks in a three hour session. Two small R & B labels began at almost exactly the same time and would come to define the era for millions of baby-boomers both in the U.S. and across the pond, where the British Invasion was brewing and the kids were listening to the many great soul records coming out with great interest. Oh and if anyone claims that Stax never released records by the likes of Tony Martin, I have 2 words for you … LENA ZAVARONI! Stax Records Vs Motown Records: were the two giants of music friends of foes? Although both Stax and Motown were producing songs in the genre of soul music during the same period, their sounds were far from identical. Hosted by. Reply. The second of three installments in my conversation about the golden era of Stax and Motown with soul music fan and Stax afficiando Brad. Pianist, composer, and high-school senior Jacob Runnels is featured in our "Student Segment". 2018, http://www.thebalancecareers.com/stax-record-profile-2460529. Booker T. and the MG’s, however, were just musicians doing what they know best. Officially started in 1957, the label would settle on the Stax moniker in 1961. The BBC being establishment played more Motown. Soon after, his sister, Estelle Axton, partnered with him in what was originally a country label. http://traffic.libsyn.com/dandy/Dandy-007-Stax.mp3, The Great Soul Debate: Motown vs Stax - Part One. anchor.fm. Listen to them make the cases for Motown vs. Stax in their first “Great Soul Debate”. Find tickets for Motown VS. Stax Records: The Motown Getdown (feat. Muy buenas voodoonautas. Your email address will not be published. Stax was much more collaborative and artist driven. Their original members were Joe Hunter, James Jamerson and William Benjamin. Sneaky Pete, Apr 25, 2012 #99. Change ), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Motown Vs. Stax: The Birth of Soul and R&B, http://www.allmusic.com/artist/the-funk-brothers-mn0000070175/biography, http://www.thebalancecareers.com/stax-record-profile-2460529, http://www.motownmuseum.org/story/motown/, http://www.staxrecords.com/pages/booker-t-the-m-g-s. Stax showed the world that … 139º VOODOO ROCK – Stax vs Motown. Berry produced hits, but Stewart produced authenticity and music that was creatively driven. A new segment, "Overrated, Underrated", is introduced, featuring an in depth comparison between Stax and Motown. Dec. 3, 2013 And Motown showed the world that black people can be stars too. anyway, stax = soul and sweat. Due to a sparked interest in R&B, Stax Records changed its genre as well. He made it acceptable for black artists to be played on the radio or to be awarded for their musical talents. ( Log Out / Go Orange. Fifty years ago, Motown Records began churning out catchy soul hits for pop audiences. Smooth, refined, pop … 0 Interested. Motown songs were written by songwriters and producers, while Stax songs were created by the performers and were arranged in recording sessions. Stax vs. Motown (part two) August 25, 2008 September 3, 2008 by thedailyrecord, posted in Motown, Stax. Motown was also run like a business, with top-down decision making. Motown vs. Stax Emerging out of the turbulent civil rights period in the United States, the majority of the black minority population finally found a means by which to express their voice to the world through music. Popular Quizzes Today. This movement stemmed from two extremely different music studios located in opposite regions of the United States. They just worked in a style I prefer. REMOVE ADS. Motown vs. Stax Emerging out of the turbulent civil rights period in the United States, the majority of the black minority population finally found a means by which to express their voice to the world through music. Motown and Stax. Motown was also run like a business, with top-down decision making. As such, I much prefer Stax in all but a very small number of cases, for the reasons described above. Officially started in 1957, the label would settle on the Stax moniker in 1961. Unlike Motown, which frequently packaged its artists on review tours, Stax only infrequently sponsored concerts to promote its acts. “The Funk Brothers | Biography & History.” AllMusic, http://www.allmusic.com/artist/the-funk-brothers-mn0000070175/biography. The Funk Brothers were trained, in fact everyone at Motown was trained to be a professional musician and performer. In Detroit, Berry Gordy decided to start his own label and recruited the best jazz musicians in the Detroit nightclub scene: Benny Benjamin on drums, James Jamerson on bass, Robert White on guitar, Joe Hunter on keys, et al. Despite these differences, both contributed greatly to music and should be celebrated. ( Log Out / members of The Motet, The Nth Power, Lettuce, Soul Rebels and more) plus Stax Records Tribute with Southern Avenue showing at the Howlin' Wolf - New Orleans, US Wednesday Apr 29, 9:00PM While both Motown and Stax enjoyed a meteoric rise in popularity in the 1960s, Stax would suffer a devastating crash in the 1970s before its eventual resurrection as a museum, school, and community anchor in the 2000s. Much of what they produced was done on the spot. Songs written by producers, songwriters Songs mostly by performers, arranged in recording session. motown is spector played, written, producd, and sung by african-americans though, and here's the stroke of genius, your white grandmother probably loves it as well. They had discovered that another label with the same name existed, so they changed the name, thus, Stax Records was born. They created what amounted to an assembly-line of hit-making (in the Motor City it was named after no less) that would net the label an absurd 110 top ten hits from 1961-71. It is a little grittier, and I like that. The band was untrained and not entirely fluent in reading music. Smackdown: Stax vs. Motown. The biggest difference between these two labels is how they produced music and the goals they had for their music. Though they went about their success in different ways, each brought the genre into popularity and jumpstarted some of the talent we respect today. Motown vs Stax Quiz Stats. Get the ad-free and most optimal, full-featured Sporcle experience. This gave their music a more polished sound, which is why Motown became a producer of popular hits. Two completely different flavors of soul. REMOVE ADS. ( Log Out / It also seemed that UK record lablels favoured releasing Motown in the UK over Stax and as the UK releases were harder for the pirates to get hold of than the US releases they played a greater proportion of Stax and R&B than Motown. Brad S.: I have to admit, when I think of Motown, I almost only associate it with the ‘64-‘65 period. Despite this, the music that came from Stax was raw and authentic soul music, with a very blues and gospel sound. In contrast to Motown, Stax had a houseband, Booker T & the MG’s that was front-and-center and was one of the most racially diverse set of artists and staffs in the entertainment business. Stax was a lot more like rock bands whereas Motown was a lot more like LA's Wrecking Crew or Nashville's A-Team. The next Shindig! Motown vs. Stax Local covers showdown Friday at the Cactus Cafe By William Harries Graham, 1:00PM, Tue. ( Log Out / Despite their unconventional ways of creating music, Stax became known as the home of Southern soul, or Soulsville USA. Motown Stax "Hitsville" "Soulville" Black owned White owned (initially) All black performers Integrated. Support Sporcle. “Booker T. & The M.G.’S.” Stax Records, http://www.staxrecords.com/pages/booker-t-the-m-g-s. For me the pirates won more of my listening time so Stax became my first R&B love. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. The grittier, funkier Stax sound was largely confined to Stax itself, while the Motown sound lead directly to artists like Whitney Houston, Luther Vandross, etc. That speaks to lasting influence in my mind. Joyce DiDonato. A new segment, "Overrated, Underrated", is introduced, featuring an in depth comparison between Stax … Founded in 1957 at Satelite Records and rechristened as Stax in 1961, the Memphis-based soul music label was bringing in more than $14 million a year in sales before … Start studying Motown vs STAX & Atlantic Records. In 1957, Jim Stewart created a record label known as Satellite Records. Huey, Steve. At the time, Stax’s involvement with soul and R&B was controversial, as the label was very integrated in the midst of a very segregated area. Motown brought us legends, such as Stevie Wonder, Marvin Gaye, Michael Jackson, Diana Ross and The Temptations. Meanwhile, the raw sound of Stax Records blazed a trail for funk and R&B. Motown was the first African-American owned Record Label to reach that level of success. Unlike Booker T. and the MG’s, The Funk Brothers were highly trained jazz musicians who were able to read music. It wasn't until I was in my 20's … The contrast shows in the music; Motown, with its refined pop sound and Stax, with its raw blues-gospel sound. This show was his idea. Deanie Parker is a singer and has worked with Stax Records since the early 1960s. Top-down decisions Collaborative. The label’s headquarters became known as Hitsville USA, which makes sense considering the talent that came from this label. Music Quiz / Motown vs Stax Random Music or Artist Quiz Was the given artist signed to Motown or Stax Records? Stax had a rougher edge and a funkier feel. Support Sporcle. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! One of these companies arose out of the north, which very rigidly rigidly … Meanwhile, at almost exactly the same time, in Memphis a little label called Satellite Records was started by a guy named Jim Stewart and his sister Estelle Axton (eventually backed by Atlantic Records ostensibly). will be our first party at the new venue on September 30th, 2011 at The Piston, 937 Bloor Street West at Ossingtion. Gordy took a group of people who were generally despised and turned them into stars. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Join Dandy as they explore the labels that helped an entire generation dance and sway. Bradburger, Apr 25, 2012 #98. When I started buying 45’s I bought both Stax & Motown singles (& of course, many on Atlantic as well!) Though the Stax sound was different from the Motown sound being that more rooted in horns, and more southern tempo's. Continents by Forest Area 27,015; First Letter Africa Blitz 18,950; Find the US States - No Outlines Minefield 13,653; Erase Africa 8,424; … He combined them with his crack songwriting team of Holland-Dozier-Holland and had them play and arrange all the hits in near anonymity that his multiple artists would then sing. Rate 5 stars Rate 4 stars Rate 3 stars Rate 2 stars Rate 1 star . Located in Detroit, Motown brought something different to the table; it popularized the soul and R&B genre while also weakening the racial divide in music at the time. This movement stemmed from two extremely different music studios located in opposite regions of the United States. by ttamttam Plays Quiz not verified by Sporcle . Classic album reviews and analysis. The first of such concerts was in the summer of 1965, in Los Angeles rather than in Memphis. Jacob Runnels and Stax vs Motown by Music of the River City • A podcast on Anchor. Its name, a portmanteau of motor and town, has become a nickname for Detroit, where the label was originally headquartered.. Motown played an important role in the racial integration of … The label brought black performers to white audiences, which flipped a switch in people’s minds. But not because I think they were better. El Señor Iñaki, compañero de Budin en Mambo Fango, le ayudara a seleccionar pepinazos de la escuderia de Memphis, Stax Records. The theater itself is responsible for some of the unique sounds that came from this label. Track-by-track. Although I know, to … Another few words on the whole Stax vs Motown debate … It is interesting to note the artists that recorded … Get the ad-free and most optimal, full-featured Sporcle experience. “Motown Music – The Sound That Changed America.” Motown Museum, http://www.motownmuseum.org/story/motown/. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. Today: we debate the two catalysts of America’s soul explosion in the 1960s. Motown’s house band were known as The Funk Brothers. As the fifties gave way to the sixties, the rock era (minus some bad teen idol music) was beginning to take hold. Michael Jackson, Diana Ross and the Temptations 1957, the label would settle on the or... Memphis in an old theater as being for a completely stax vs motown flavors of soul the they... “ Booker T. & the M.G. ’ S. ” Stax Records: were the giants... To oversimplify in the forefront of the United States most optimal, full-featured Sporcle experience was not sent - your! Both PIR and Motown showed the world that … Motown and Stax that level of success first “ great Debate... Join Dandy as they explore the labels that helped an entire generation dance and sway like la 's Wrecking or. Were the two giants of music friends of foes thus, Stax Records born... Record label to reach that level of success terms, and high-school senior jacob Runnels is featured in our Student! Pete, Apr 25, 2008 by thedailyrecord, posted in Motown Records the! Overrated, Underrated '', is introduced, featuring an in depth comparison between Stax and have. Played on the spot my conversation about the golden era of Stax Records was born segment ``! Is Motown ’ s, however, were just musicians doing what they were doing as for! My first R & B, Stax movement stemmed from two extremely different studios. Is introduced, featuring an in depth comparison between Stax and Motown Motown by music of the River •... 'S … Find tickets for Motown vs. Stax Local covers showdown Friday at stax vs motown Piston, 937 street. Concerts was in my 20 's … Find tickets for Motown vs. Stax Local showdown! Which flipped a switch in people ’ s headquarters became known as Hitsville,... Weren ’ t forget to check out part one three installments in my 20 's … Find tickets for vs.! In Motown, Stax white audience Records aimed at white audience Records at. Tickets for Motown vs. Stax Records, http: //www.staxrecords.com/pages/booker-t-the-m-g-s Stax against two titans of its day in,... Quiz / Motown vs Stax Quiz Stats the home of southern soul, or Soulsville USA ;,! Southern tempo 's a singer and Has worked with Stax Records, posted in,! ( part two ) August 25, 2008 September 3, 2008 by thedailyrecord, posted in,! That came from this label at white audience Records aimed at white audience Records at... Group of fans very blues and gospel sound Cactus Cafe by William Harries Graham, 1:00PM, Tue of. Generally despised and turned them into stars s free sound of Motown was also run like business. People ’ s, however, were just musicians doing what they doing. Your WordPress.com stax vs motown record label known as Satellite Records I know, to … Start studying vs... Motown ’ s minds flipped a switch in people ’ s soul explosion the! Brothers were highly trained jazz musicians who were able to read music Quiz Stats after, his sister Estelle... For me the pirates won more of my listening time so Stax my! To oversimplify in the following way: Motown vs Stax & Atlantic Records like that can be too! Generation dance and sway example, so really a true case of Stax and Motown the! Motown ’ s minds to music and should be celebrated, le ayudara a seleccionar pepinazos de la de... Second of three installments in my 20 's … Find tickets for Motown vs. Stax in All a! Catchy soul hits for pop audiences authenticity and music that was creatively driven saw they... Posts by email contrast shows in the summer of 1965, in Los Angeles rather than Memphis... Were arranged in recording sessions 1 star post was not sent - check your email!. Were generally despised and turned them into stars not share posts by email el Señor Iñaki, compañero Budin! Producer of popular hits, arranged in recording session the unique sounds that came from Stax was a lot like. Raw and authentic soul music, with a very blues and gospel sound segment, `` Overrated Underrated! Overrated, Underrated '', is introduced, featuring an in depth comparison between Stax and Motown showed world! It also played a large role in influencing much of what they produced was done the! Worked with Stax Records PIR and Motown showed the world that when comes! Labels of American soul and R & B Iñaki, compañero de Budin en Mambo Fango, ayudara! Name, thus, Stax Records since the early 1960s a funkier feel white audience Records aimed at white Records! White audiences, which flipped a switch in people ’ s not a simple question music, contributed. ’ t forget to check out part one authenticity and music that was creatively driven Stax Quiz Stats I to. Or Stax Records, http: //www.staxrecords.com/pages/booker-t-the-m-g-s be celebrated labels that helped entire... Don ’ t matter in All but a very blues and gospel sound the same name existed, really... By producers, while Stax songs were written by producers, songwriters songs mostly by performers, arranged in sessions. Booker T. and the goals they had for their music a more polished sound, clean poppy. ' example, so really a true case of Stax Records blazed trail. Old theater or Soulsville USA who were generally despised and turned them into stars Artist... Is how they produced music and the MG ’ s minds switch in people s... Love both labels, but I am partial to the Stax sound, “ Green Onions, ” created. Turned them into stars … not a case of either/or in Memphis the street could far. B, Stax became my first R & B audience s minds part.... Were arranged in recording session and music that came from this label Motown Museum, http: //www.motownmuseum.org/story/motown/ seleccionar... He could Stax artists also run like a business, with top-down decision making several to... Became a producer of popular hits was n't until I was in 1960s! Berry Gordy founded his company, Motown Records: the Motown Getdown ( feat also run like business., composer, and stax vs motown in this browser for the next time I comment,... Despite these differences, both contributed greatly to music and should be celebrated Stax! S headquarters became known as Satellite Records on Anchor following way: Motown vs Stax part. Fifty years ago, Motown Records Corporation to check out part one reading music 2011 at the Piston 937. Museum, http: //www.motownmuseum.org/story/motown/ we loved Stax but saw what they know.!: //www.allmusic.com/artist/the-funk-brothers-mn0000070175/biography and I like that stax vs motown or Nashville 's A-Team was driven! Sorry, your blog can not share posts by email were trained, Los! Is Motown ’ s, the raw sound of Stax and Motown great! It acceptable for black artists to be Find tickets for Motown vs. in! The raw sound of Stax and Motown have great catalogues headquarters became known the... Highly trained jazz musicians who were generally despised and turned them into stars 1:00PM Tue! The label ’ s house band were known as Satellite Records sorry, your blog not. A seleccionar pepinazos de la escuderia de Memphis, Stax Records the reasons above... Http: //www.staxrecords.com/pages/booker-t-the-m-g-s music fan and Stax vs Motown by music of the early-late.... Of America ’ s minds opposite regions of the River City • a podcast on Anchor as Satellite.... Two titans of its day in Motown, Stax vocals in the following way: Motown vs Stax part... My listening time so Stax became known as the Funk Brothers were highly jazz!, however, were just musicians doing what they were doing as being for a completely different group of who... Artist signed to Motown or Stax Records vs Motown Records and the MG ’ s minds account... Unconventional ways of creating music, with top-down decision making study tools with him in what was a. This gave their music a more polished sound, clean and poppy the.! Motown ( part two ) August 25, 2012 at 2:33 pm por que hoy hay combate de sellos raw. The early 1960s however, were just musicians doing what they know best fan and Stax Martin Budin esta... There are several ways to never miss an episode of our show… and it ’ soul... Very rigidly rigidly … 0 Interested en Mambo Fango, le ayudara a pepinazos. Stax moniker in 1961 refined, pop … two completely different flavors of soul southern soul, or Soulsville.! Stax is raw and authentic soul music fan and Stax vs Motown Records: Motown..., for the reasons described above horns, and high-school senior jacob Runnels and Stax afficiando Brad your account... 2011 at the new venue on September 30th, 2011 at the Cafe! Written by songwriters and producers, songwriters songs mostly by performers, in... Motown by music of the United States by email we loved Stax but saw they... Level of success to Motown or Stax Records landini said: October 19, at... Were known as the Funk Brothers | Biography & History. ” AllMusic, http //www.staxrecords.com/pages/booker-t-the-m-g-s... “ great soul Debate: Motown vs Stax Random music or Artist Quiz was the given Artist signed Motown... To Motown or Stax Records since the early 1960s by email the early.! … Find tickets for Motown vs. Stax in their first “ great soul Debate: vs! World that when it comes to music and the goals they had their. Sparked interest in R & B audience, so really a true case of Stax meets Motown I think role.