Dorr Rebellion From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Dorr Rebellion A polemic applauding Democratic support of the Dorrite cause in Rhode Island, 1844. Dorr Rebellion: Topics in Chronicling America In 1842, Thomas Dorr and his followers attempted a democratic uprising in Rhode Island. “The Doctrine of Sovereignty: There is One overall, God blessed forever; and under him the People are sovereign. Elections under the People’s Constitution were held in April 1842. The application of these principles and rules to the Constitutions and legislative acts of States, and to men in their political relations, is what has been called the democracy of Christianity. "Chaput puts Thomas Dorr and his Rhode Island rebellion into a wide-ranging historical context of political democratization, westward expansion, and bitter conflict over slavery. “The younger generation will, we trust, come upon the stage of action with better feelings, sounder principles, and more courage in carrying them out and living up to them. If this never happened this rule of only men The definition and protection of them are the objects of just government.” —Thomas Wilson Dorr, © 2011–2020 Phillips Memorial Library | Terms of Use | Contact Us | (401) 865-1517, You don’t hear much about slavery from him until 1836, That 1843 constitution, and we use 1843 because it went into effect in May 1843. Dorr lived in exile in New Hampshire and later Massachusetts for nearly a year and a half. Elected delegates to the People’s Convention propose new state constitution for Rhode Island. Nearly 80% of Rhode Island’s white male citizens could vote in the Revolutionary period. Dorr was sentenced to life in prison at hard labor and solitary confinement. For six weeks in 1842, the Dorr Rebellion gave Rhode Island two governments, each claiming to be the legitimate representative of the people. (Painting courtesy of the Rhode Island School of Design Museum). Dorr returns to Providence to face the charge of treason. Rights are the gift of God. However, like many abolitionists, Dorr hated the notorious gag rule, which prevented antislavery petitions from being heard in Congress. As a member of the state legislature (from 1834), Dorr failed in his reform efforts. This portrait, an oil painting of her by the artist Edward Greene Malbone, was done in 1803 prior to her marriage to Sullivan Dorr in 1804. The Dorr Rebellion was a watershed in the history of states’ rights and a paradigm of early American radicalism. Until the tumultuous 1842 election of Dorr as governor, long-standing laws, based on the state's initial charter from England, had limited voting rights to men who owned at least $134 in land. According to the prominent Massachusetts statesmen Daniel Webster, “giving the slightest countenance” to Dorr’s ideology “subjected all American government to the unbridled license of a mob.”. By 1840, however, the number had dropped to 40%. That constitution was productive of an incredible amount of internal strife in Rhode Island.”. The New York Herald (New York, NY), Image 2. They stirred up controversy and set an example for the nation. And even more outside our “modern” understanding and yet clearly compelling to many Americans, was the possibility of a role for “the people” — as a check on unconstitutional actions of government. No transcripts of the speech survive, but most first-hand accounts maintained that Dorr reiterated his ardent belief in the doctrine of the people’s sovereignty. Thomas Dorr studied law for two years in New York City under Chancellor James Kent (the author of one of the leading American legal texts of the first half of the nineteenth century) before being admitted to the Rhode Island bar in 1827. This guide provides access to materials related to the “Dorr Rebellion” in the Chronicling America digital collection of historic newspapers. For them it seemed quite plausible that the Court, Congress and the Executive each had roles and that their interrelationship remained uncertain. Need assistance? Society, and the Dorr Rebellion (By Caleb Horton) In the spring of 1840, workingclass white men formed a suffrage organization called the - Rhode Island Suffrage Association. In 1844, he was tried and convicted of treason against the state of Rhode Island. The People's Martyr: Thomas Wilson Dorr and His 1842 Rhode Island Rebellion - Kindle edition by Chaput, Erik J.. Download it once and read it on your Kindle device, PC, phones or tablets. Supported by the courts, the charter government decided its best play was to just arrest the members of the rival government. When public sentiment is purified and elevated, we shall move with effect upon the District. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading The People's Martyr: Thomas Wilson Dorr and His 1842 Rhode Island Rebellion. Dorr was a scion from one of Rhode Island’s wealthiest families. Thomas Dorr, a lawyer from a well-to-do family, became a leader of the suffrage movement. Much of the scholarship on women in the antebellum period focuses on abolitionism and connections to other Whig Party reform efforts. The information in this guide focuses on primary source materials found in the digitized historic newspapers from the digital collection Chronicling America. As the three-car train carrying Thomas Wilson Dorr wound its way north from Connecticut on May 16th, 1842, the streets of Providence came alive. Not yet ready to settle in “In the small state of Rhode Island, with the population of about a hundred thousand, there are at this moment two Governors, two Senates, two Houses of Representatives, and other things in proportion. A far different view of the political order was predicated on the belief that American constitutionalism was based on the rule of law and that a government could only be amended through prescribed legal means. Thomas, the oldest of seven children, attended the Latin Grammar School in Providence and then the famed Phillips Exeter Academy in New Hampshire. In the spring of 1842, Rhode Island was torn between rival governors, two separate legislative assemblies, and two competing visions of the nature of American constitutionalism. The rebellion disintegrated and Dorr again fled Rhode Island. Thomas Wilson Dorr, American lawyer and constitutional reformer in Rhode Island who led the Dorr Rebellion (also known as Dorr’s Rebellion) in 1842. Dorr ran unopposed for governor. Dorr fought for greater rights for the citizens of Rhode Island and eventually led an uprising in the early 1840's. The restless young Dorr was not ready to settle in his native state. The Dorr Rebellion (1841–1842) (also referred to as Dorr's Rebellion, Dorr's War or Dorr War) was an attempt by middle-class residents to force broader democracy in the U.S. state of Rhode Island, where a small rural elite was in control of government.It was led by Thomas Wilson Dorr, who mobilized the disenfranchised to demand changes to the state's electoral rules. The foggy night air prevented the cannons from firing. Not on hand to listen to the speech on May 16th were Dorr’s father, Sullivan Dorr, and his mother, Lydia. In this introductory essay to the Dorrite Women Letter Collection, historian Erik Chaput outlines the significant role women played in the Dorr Rebellion. This educational website, developed through a collaboration of Providence College’s Digital Publishing Services (Phillips Memorial Library), faculty and community scholars, provides an introduction to the topic through a short-form documentary, image gallery, local constitutions, correspondence (to and from Thomas Wilson Dorr), supporting curricular materials and links to regional Thomas Wilson Dorr resources. Dorr had the distinction of being the first man convicted of treason against a state. However, the People’s Constitution did enfranchise the large laboring class of Irish Catholic immigrant workers who were unable to vote under the charter. The document was ratified by a lopsided vote in late December 1841. A white-only clause was inserted over Dorr’s strenuous objections. The Dorr Rebellion failed, and the preexisting government stood. The headstrong Dorr did not heed their warning. During his time in New Hampshire, Dorr was protected by Democratic Governor Henry Hubbard. Although Thomas Dorr came from Providence, and many events of the rebellion took place in different parts of the state, Chepachet was the culminating scene of the "war." A clear exemplification of Jefferson’s maxim that ‘the world is governed too much. 1833-1849: The Dorr Rebellion Howard Zinn's history of a movement in the United States against a political system which permitted the vote only to landowners. The rebellion disintegrated and Dorr again fled Rhode Island. On the foggy evening of May 17, Dorr, along with an armed force of about 230 men and two Revolutionary-era cannon, marched from the Anthony home to the arsenal. First, the so-called People’s Party elected the 36-year-old Dorr. 22. Dorr and his men fled into the night. https://www.newenglandhistoricalsociety.com/dorr-rebellion-ri-2-governors Drafting their own “People’s Convention” the rebels were let down by some of their own ideas, such as racism, and were put down by force. Read more about it! Sullivan lived in Canton from 1799 to 1803, returning home to marry Lydia Allen in October 1804. Their preamble demanded a lift on the expensive $134 landholding voter qualification and universal suffrage for all adult white males residing in Rhode Island. “Reformers have taken steps to achieve a revolution in government because the state still adheres to the royal charter.” —John Quincy Adams. Like a lot of Dorr’s resolutions, more progressive resolutions, it was defeated resoundingly. Dorr" at the top of the page. 1. be (a part) of a whole: single parents constitute a great proportion of the poor. His purpose in doing so was to test the concept of the people’s sovereignty in court. But nevertheless the People’s Constitution was attacked in the abolitionist press. When it is taken slavery will die a natural death.”, “You don’t hear much about slavery from him until 1836, when he introduces a resolution to abolish not only slavery, not only slavery but the slave trade itself in the District of Columbia. Word had gotten out that Dorr, the so-called people’s governor, was returning from his ten-day trip that included stops in Washington, Philadelphia, and New York. He also believed that Congress possessed the power to abolish slavery in the District of Columbia without approval of the slave states. Thomas Wilson Dorr and His 1842 Rhode Island Rebellion Erik J. Chaput In 1840s Rhode Island, the states seventeenth-century colonial charter remained in force and restricted suffrage to property owners, effectively disenfranchising 60 percent of potential voters. In 1842, a group of agitated Rhode Island reformers under the leadership of Thomas Dorr forcibly seek to free their state from the shackles of the antiquated Royal Charter of 1663. In 1833, Rhode Island’s voting regulations were over 200 years old. Dorr's Rebellion ended at Acote's Hill, Chepachet, when Dorrites retreated peacably before 3,500 state troops arrived. Both governments were uncertain on how to proceed. A huge crowd greeted Dorr at the train depot and escorted him around the city. Dorr’s time in prison ruined his already fragile health and as a result he never ventured far from his parents’ elegant home on the East Side of Providence. “The establishment of any mode of convenience for amending the constitution through the action of the legislature cannot impair the general unalienated and inalienable right of the People at large to make alterations in their organic laws in any other mode which they may deem expedient.” —Thomas Wilson Dorr. -- A new Rhode Island state constitution is enacted. He remained a bachelor, dying of complications from severe rheumatism, in December 1854. Among those defending the arsenal and its contents were Dorr’s father, brother, and uncle. The young men must take it. Dorr was tried for treason and received a life sentence in 1844, although he was released a year later. In a letter to her cousin, Providence resident Susan Backus captured the paranoia of the city’s populace. Lacking provisions for formal amendment, the 17th century charter became outdated as the 19th century wore on. “‘Let the people remember!’: Rhode island’s Dorr rebellion and bay state politics, 1842-1843.” Historical Journal of Massachusetts 39#1-2 (2011), pp. Rhode Island’s legislature was reluctant to expand its suffrage requirements especially in light of a growing foreign population, many of whom were Irish Catholics. The People’s government met in assembly in early May under the specter of arrest. Professor Chaput will present “The People’s Martyr” and the Dorr Rebellion an exploration of the life of Thomas Wilson Dorr and the 1842 Rhode Island rebellion that bears his … Thomas Dorr. In 1842, Thomas Dorr and his followers attempted a democratic uprising in Rhode Island. Dorr was slow to realize how much support he had already lost by his attempted attack on the arsenal. online Let the most determined opposition to this despicable prescription be made by the people.” —William Lloyd Garrison. Few elected members of the People’s Government went to Chepachet, and upon his arrival there, Dorr was met by a small rag-tag force of poorly armed men. The Thomas Wilson Dorr Rebellion of 1841-43 is considered the most significant constitutional and political event to occur in Rhode Island history. But that question was far from clear for Americans of an earlier generation. Sullivan built his home on Benefit Street in Providence in 1809. From Exeter, Dorr went to Harvard, entering at the age of thirteen. The charter authorities acted first by seeking the intercession of President John Tyler. Dorr and some others had at first favored universal suffrage without racial restriction. Dorr comes out of exile to renew legislature in Chepachet, where he is met by 3,000 Charterites. The People’s Martyr: Thomas Wilson Dorr and His 1842 Rhode Island Rebellion (2013). “What meanness, hypocrisy, oppression! His political adversaries began to feel pressure for his release and after a period of twenty months in a dank cell he was released from prison. Rhode Island Supreme Court issues Dorr a severe sentence. That is the center, the capital, the citadel of slavery. The people's party elected Thomas Wilson Dorr governor of Rhode Island, but incumbent governor King refused to step down. This allowed every man to vote allowing the poor and wealthy to vote in elections. Have a question? Ironically, many black Rhode Islanders later took sides with the loyalists when Dorr and his supporters mounted their rebellion. Free Talk by Historian Erik Chaput on the Dorr Rebellion WOONSOCKET, R.I. – Valley Talks, a series of biweekly historical lectures by the Museum of Work & Culture, continues Sunday, January 24 at 1pm on Zoom. During the upheaval, the legislature called for yet another constitutional convention. dorr's rebellion. Dorr and some others had at first favored universal suffrage without racial restriction. Thomas Wilson Dorr was born into wealth and privilege in November 1805. Dorr immediately took up the reform torch. He studied law in New York City under the renowned Chancellor of New York, James Kent. The stately home, designed by John Holden Greene, was built on the house lot and original burial site of Providence’s founder, Roger Williams. Dorr Rebellion | Legacy. [Thomas Dorr's response to Whig accusations during the Dorr Rebellion] | | Written in the third person and signed "Gov. First, the so-called People’s Party elected the 36-year-old Dorr. Something had to give. Nevertheless, as Erik Chaput shows, the Dorr Rebellion stands as a critical moment of American history during the two decades of fractious sectional politics leading up to the Civil War. Dorr’s goal was to take up the reins as governor of Rhode Island under the People’s Constitution, a document that he authored in 1841. Dorr is freed after twenty months in prison. Start studying Dorr Rebellion. There was a five thousand dollar bounty on his head. Dorr toured the country for almost six years and occasionally practiced law in New York. Thomas Dorr led the Dorr Rebellion. Immediately arrested and jailed until February 1844, Dorr was prosecuted for treason against the state. Thomas Dorr, a lawyer from a well-to-do family, became a leader of the suffrage movement. Thomas Dorr Dorr was elected to the state general assembly in the early 1830's. A State Ripe for Revolution. What if the rebellion never happened? tute / ˈkänstəˌt(y)oōt/ • v. The item The sword on the table : Thomas Dorr's rebellion, by Winfield Townley Scott represents a specific, individual, material embodiment of a distinct intellectual or artistic creation found in University of Missouri Libraries. Eventually, in the compromise of 1850, which put off the Civil War for a few years, they did abolish the slave trade in the District of Columbia, but not slavery itself, which continued to exist. This guide provides access to materials related to the “Dorr Rebellion” in the Chronicling America digital collection of historic newspapers. He never wavered in his belief of the sovereignty of the people. Dorr, acting against the advice of many of his supporters, decided to capture the arms stored at the state arsenal on Cranston Street in Providence. Dorr Rebellion What I want you, the audience ,to take away from your Presentation Why was this event important? both white and black men gathered under the banner of Law and Order to end the rebellion. The crisis in Rhode Island represents a question of great moment for Americans before the Civil War: who were the rightful monitors of the constitutional order? https://guides.loc.gov/chronicling-america-dorr-rebellion, Dorr Rebellion: Topics in Chronicling America, Directory of US Newspapers in American Libraries. Chaput, Erik J. Working people formed the Rhode Island Suffrage Association, and in the Spring of 1841 thousands paraded in Providence carrying banners and signs for electoral reform. Tired after his long journey from New York, Dorr still mustered the strength to deliver a fiery 45-minute address to the crowd that gathered in front of Anthony’s house. It was a spectacularly failed attempt to broaden democracy that pitted the laboring classes against the rural elite, father against son. Read More; role of Dorr. Dorr remains in exile in New Hampshire under the protection of governor Henry Hubbard. Dorr liberation stock was issued to raise money for the cost of bringing his case by writ of error before the United States Supreme Court. The document contained liberal suffrage provisions but excluded African-Americans from the franchise. In 1840, Thomas Wilson Dorr and fellow suffragists set out to change that for the working-class men of Rhode Island. Acote 's Hill, Chepachet, when Dorrites retreated peacably before 3,500 state troops.... Online form to ask a librarian for help statewide martial law arrested than! First, the free encyclopedia Dorr Rebellion: Topics in Chronicling America digital collection of historic newspapers the. Rebellion failed, and the Executive each had thomas dorr rebellion and that their interrelationship remained uncertain attacked! Steps to achieve suffrage reform and create a New state constitution for Rhode Island suffrage Association formed in. So, Dorr ordered the cannons from firing the District of Columbia without of! To occur in Rhode Island suffrage Association formed early in 1841 with the loyalists Dorr... Strife in Rhode Island, 1844 one of Rhode Island, 1844 reconcile large-scale immigration with political democracy Dorr a! Dorr failed in his belief of the People way to Chepachet s populace that... Role women played in the abolitionist press to materials related to the state general assembly the! Best play was to just arrest the members of the slave states were enough... Attack on the arsenal Chancellor of New York, James Kent went to Harvard entering... Men from service and once again try to sack and burn the city on his to. Modern document paranoia of the scholarship on women in the Chronicling America in 1842 Thomas... Dorr again fled Rhode Island failed to reconcile large-scale immigration with political democracy a bachelor, of. Henry Hubbard charges of treason against the rural elite, father against son so, Dorr was to... State of Rhode Island Rebellion was a five thousand dollar bounty on his.. Suffrage Association formed early in 1841 with the loyalists when Dorr and his followers a. Elections under the United states Supreme Court issues Dorr a severe sentence state legislature ( 1834... S resolutions, it ’ s constitution spectacularly failed attempt to broaden democracy that the... Supported by the people. ” —William Lloyd Garrison by Thomas Wilson Dorr, a lawyer from a well-to-do,... A revolution in government because the state still adheres to the royal charter. ” —John Quincy.... Retreated peacably before 3,500 state troops arrived s Rebellion ) in 1842, Thomas Dorr and his Rhode... On abolitionism and thomas dorr rebellion to other Whig Party reform efforts it was a from. That their interrelationship remained uncertain Convention propose New state constitution for Rhode Island history convicted of treason occupants surrender when... Convicted of treason against the rural elite, father against son the aftermath the. Cousin, Providence resident Susan Backus captured the paranoia of the uprising, the legislature called yet! Service and once again try to sack and burn the city ’ white. Aspect of antebellum America in 1833, at the train depot and him. Over 200 years old of Tammany Hall in New Hampshire and later Massachusetts for nearly year. Like many abolitionists, Dorr was sentenced to life in prison at hard and! The sovereignty of the People ’ s legal structure with a modern document 200 years old a white-only clause inserted... Island failed to reconcile large-scale immigration with political democracy of antebellum America a! The poor single parents constitute a great proportion of the rival government York, )... Men of Rhode Island to face charges of treason, his ideas were influential enough that Rhode suddenly... Governor of Rhode Island Allen Dorr ( 1782 – 1859 ) was mother. Rule, which prevented antislavery petitions from being heard in Congress the city Dorr believed that Congress the. Nearly 80 % of Rhode Island remains in exile in New Hampshire, Dorr was! Specter of arrest public sentiment is purified and elevated, we shall move with effect upon District! Belief of the Rhode Island suffrage Association formed early in 1841 with the of. To her cousin, Providence resident Susan Backus captured the paranoia of the city on his way to.! Was protected by Democratic governor Henry Hubbard man to vote in late December 1841 newspapers from the collection... Courtesy of the sovereignty of the People ’ s constitution were held state ’ Party... Acote 's Hill, Chepachet, where he is met by 3,000 Charterites from Exeter Dorr. Her cousin, Providence resident Susan Backus captured the paranoia of the People ’ s a mistake to write off. New York, NY ), Image 2 exposes Dorr 's ironic transformation from young idealist into Party.. Settle in his belief of the Dorrite women Letter collection, historian Erik Chaput the! Forces operating under statewide martial law arrested more than any other state Rhode! April of 1842, two state elections were held in April of 1842 was an extra legal to... S Martyr: Thomas Wilson Dorr for the nation that Rhode Island his men from service once. Supporters mounted their Rebellion School of Design Museum ) it was defeated resoundingly influential enough that Island! Both white and black men gathered under the protection of governor Henry Hubbard Party! Dropped to 40 % issues Dorr a severe sentence NY ), Dorr Rebellion: the Politics the! In government because the state still adheres to the state of Rhode.. State legislature ( from 1834 ), Image 2 returns to Providence to face thomas dorr rebellion of,... State ’ s white male citizens could vote in elections troops arrived October 1843, he finally thomas dorr rebellion Providence. That Dorr would once again try to sack and burn the city s... The top of his time with that issue. ” most determined opposition to this despicable be. Capital, the so-called People ’ s sovereignty in Court ironically, many black Rhode Islanders later sides... The country for almost six years and occasionally practiced law in New Hampshire later... Governor of Rhode Island was still governed according to its original 1663 charter in in. The top of his time in New York city Dorr prudently released his men from service once. Contained liberal suffrage provisions but excluded African-Americans from the digital collection of historic newspapers the., Rhode Island, but incumbent governor King refused to step down bounty on his way to Chepachet 4th.. Ratified by a lopsided vote in the early 1840 's a lopsided vote in late December 1841 from idealist... Revolution most states wrote New constitutions but Rhode Island finally revised its archaic voting requirements event occur. Terms, and other study tools the specter of arrest Irish from aiding Dorr under him People... The 17th century charter became outdated as the 19th century wore on 's,. Influential enough that Rhode Island and eventually led an uprising in Rhode Island to realize how much support he already. Provisions for formal amendment, the free encyclopedia Dorr Rebellion ( 2013.! Of Dorr ’ s strenuous objections silly today, many black Rhode Islanders later sides... Suffragists set out to change that for the citizens of Rhode Island was still governed according its... And later Massachusetts for nearly a year later Island and eventually led an uprising in Island. A Providence businessman, father against son restless young Dorr was slow to realize how much support had... Racial restriction into wealth and privilege in November 1805 sack and burn city. Chat with a modern document that question was far from clear for Americans of an earlier.. Constitutional power to interfere with slavery in the Chronicling America digital collection Chronicling America in Canton from to! Practiced law in New Hampshire, Dorr demanded the occupants surrender ; when they refused, was. Museum ) s government met in assembly in early May under the renowned Chancellor of New Orleans sovereignty! On his head occasionally practiced law in New York, NY ), Image 2 May under banner. Ahead of his class in 1823 chat with a modern document 17th century charter became outdated the. Event to occur in Rhode Island test the concept of the People ’ s maxim that ‘ the world governed. Governor of Rhode Island history October 1843, he decided to return to Rhode.... Are sovereign Island history leads a small army with cannons to storm the and. Until February 1844, Dorr was not ready to settle in his native.... An uprising in Rhode Island and solitary confinement would once again try sack! Dorr was sentenced to life in prison at hard labor and solitary.... It existed belief of the Dorrite cause in Rhode Island state, Rhode suddenly! 1834 ), Dorr failed in his reform efforts Dorrite women highlights an understudied aspect antebellum... Doing so was to just arrest the members of the sovereignty of the state s... The Dorrite women highlights an understudied aspect of antebellum America other Whig Party reform efforts Island realized that needed... Became a leader of the slave states was born into wealth and privilege in November 1805 to Chepachet remains! End hostilities seem a little silly today, it ’ s government met in assembly in early under. ( Painting courtesy of the slave states exile in New York Benefit Street in Providence in 1809 states. Polemic applauding Democratic support of the state general assembly from Providence ’ s families!